- Research article
- Open Access
Aerobic exercise in adolescents with obesity: preliminary evaluation of a modular training program and the modified shuttle test
BMC Pediatrics volume 7, Article number: 19 (2007)
Increasing activity levels in adolescents with obesity requires the development of exercise programs that are both attractive to adolescents and easily reproducible. The aim of this study was to develop a modular aerobic training program for adolescents with severe obesity, with a focus on variety, individual targets and acquiring physical skills. We report here the effects on aerobic fitness from a pilot study. Furthermore, we examined the feasibility of the modified shuttle test (MST) as an outcome parameter for aerobic fitness in adolescents with severe obesity.
Fifteen adolescents from an inpatient body weight management program participated in the aerobic training study (age 14.7 ± 2.1 yrs, body mass index 37.4 ± 3.5). The subjects trained three days per week for 12 weeks, with each session lasting 30–60 minutes. The modular training program consisted of indoor, outdoor and swimming activities. Feasibility of the MST was studied by assessing construct validity, test-retest reliability and sensitivity to change.
Comparing pretraining and end of training period showed large clinically relevant and significant improvements for all aerobic indices: e.g. VO2 peak 17.5%, effect size (ES) 2.4; Wmax 8%, ES 0.8. In addition, a significant improvement was found for the efficiency of the cardiovascular system as assessed by the oxygen pulse (15.8%, ES 1.6).
Construct validity, test-retest reliability and sensitivity to change of the MST were very good. MST was significantly correlated with VO2 peak (r = 0.79) and Wmax (r = 0.84) but not with anthropometric measures. The MST walking distance improved significantly by 32.5%, ES 2.5. The attendance rate at the exercise sessions was excellent.
This modular, varied aerobic training program has clinically relevant effects on aerobic performance in adolescents with severe obesity. The added value of our aerobic training program for body weight management programs for adolescents with severe obesity should be studied with a randomized trial. This study further demonstrated that the MST is a reliable, sensitive and easy to administer outcome measure for aerobic fitness in adolescent body weight management trials.
Along with dietary and behavior treatment components, exercise or physical activity is generally considered one of the cornerstones of pediatric obesity treatment. Increasing energy expenditure may accelerate loss of fat mass by creating a negative energy balance, changes in body composition, and potentiate the maintenance of changes in body composition[6, 7].
The majority of studies in overweight or obese children and adolescents have focused on aerobic exercise. These studies indicate that aerobic exercise has little effect on gross measures such as bodyweight and body mass index (BMI), but is usually associated with favorable changes in body composition. Aerobic exercise may decrease body fat, attenuate the loss of lean body mass normally seen during dietary energy restriction and mediate the accumulation of visceral adipose tissue. The latter is associated with cardiovascular risk in the pediatric population.
Epstein and colleagues speculated that being able to choose one's own activities may be perceived as having control over being more physically active. Both choice and perceived control has shown to be important determinants of exercise adherence. Obese children and adolescents often lack confidence in their physical ability. Therefore, it is important to balance training guidelines and experimental control over the characteristics of an exercise program versus enhancing self-confidence and perceived self-efficacy. Self-efficacy denotes the belief an individual has in his or her ability to engage in a specific behavior. Thus, physical self-efficacy represents skills in a physical task. The acquisition of skills is needed to promote self-efficacy of adolescents. However, decreasing sedentary activity seems a more promising approach than increasing physical activity for body weight management. Incorporating a variety of physical activities in a structured exercise program possibly represent a method of reinforcing reduction in sedentary behaviours and choosing one's own physical activities under free living conditions.
Resting energy expenditure (REE) is very important because REE represents a significant share of the total energy expenditure. Up to 80% of daily energy expenditure occurs at rest and relative to adipose tissue, lean body mass has a high basal metabolic rate. Hence, preservation of lean body is an effective way of increasing daily energy expenditure and thereby decreasing fat mass. In addition, it may positively influence long-term outcome.
Childhood obesity increases the risk of obesity in adulthood where the health risks are well established. Some epidemiological data indicate that aerobic fitness, rather than fatness, may be the most appropriate target for lifestyle interventions [17–23]. Studies in overweight and obese adults have demonstrated that low cardiovascular fitness is as important as BMI for predicting mortality[24, 25]. This hypothesis is supported by recent pediatric studies [26–28].
It has been proposed that encouraging the development of physical activity habits in children, and reinforcing these habits in adolescents, helps establish patterns that continue into adulthood. In addition, obesity and low initial levels of fitness may attenuate the positive consequences associated with being active and reduce the motivation to keep up an exercise program.
There are several reports in the literature about exercise programs for adolescents with obesity [30–35]. However, the focus of most programs is on long-lasting endurance activities, which in our opinion are boring for the pediatric population. Furthermore, most programs are not easily reproducible due to lack of detail or requirement of special equipment. Therefore, our aim was to develop a modular aerobic exercise program that is attractive to adolescents with obesity and easily reproducible by others. Several requirements can be defined for such an exercise program.
First, an exercise program for adolescents should include a variety of physical activities to increase the physical skills of the participants. Second, activities at the beginning of the program should focus on gains in self-confidence and perceived self-efficacy. Third, a training program should be individualized. Fourth, the program should be enjoyable with a wide variation of exercises. Fifth, a program should preferably be developed with an open format.
The second aim of this study is to report on an easily administred exercise test that suits the exercise program. Formal laboratory-based exercise tests with on-line analysis of expired air are considered the gold standard for measuring aerobic training effects. However, these tests are time-consuming, expensive and the required specialized equipment is not widely available[38, 39]. In addition, many subjects with obesity find these tests excessively stressful and are reluctant to perform these tests on a routine basis. Therefore, there is a need for a simple practical method of measuring aerobic fitness in adolescents with obesity. For this purpose a test should be incremental and progressive in nature, stressing the subject to a symptom limited maximal performance. Drinkard et al used the 12-minute walk/run in adolescents with obesity. The 12-minute walk/run is a self paced test which may be influenced by motivation. The subject sets the pace throughout the test. This raises the likelihood that maximum cardiorespiratory values are not reached. The incremental, externally paced 20 meter shuttle running test is a widely used field test of functional capacity in children [41–43]. However, the starting speed of the 20 meter shuttle running test is too fast for children with obesity. The modified shuttle test (MST) may be more suitable for children with obesity, as it has a much slower start with increments of 0.17 m/s each minute.
In summary, the goals of this pilot study are to outline a varied aerobic exercise program and evaluate it's feasibility and preliminary outcomes, and to assess the feasibility of the modified shuttle test (validity, reliability, repeatability and sensitivity) for evaluating aerobic fitness in pediatric obesity.
Subjects and study design
Pediatric patients with obesity were recruited from the pediatric department of Treatment Center Heideheuvel at Hilversum. Inclusion criteria: children aged 10–18 years with obesity (BMI = 30) who were referred for the multidisciplinary body weight management program. Exclusion criterion: musculo-skeletal disorders. Fifteen consecutive patients met the inclusion criteria. All agreed to participate in the aerobic training study. All children in the aerobic training study were new patients. The local institutional Ethics Committee approved the study protocol. Informed consent was obtained from all participants and their parents.
The baseline measurements were done in the first week of admission. Anthropometric measurements and the cardiopulmonary exercise test were done on day one and day three. On day three and day five the shuttle tests were conducted. The tests were repeated within five days after the training program was finished. The subjects continued their normal daily treatment during the aerobic training study.
Multidisciplinary body weight management program
The multidisciplinary body weight management program consists of dietary (protein sparing diet), exercise and family-based interventions, medical treatment in case of complications, and behavior modification.
The caloric requirements of each child were measured using the Schofield-formula, presuming a P50 weight for length. Thus, caloric restriction is limited as long as the child's weight exceeds this parameter. The guiding principle in the treatment program is that both the child and its parents must learn to accustom themselves to a new dietary pattern (as to content, composition, preparation etcetera) which can also be maintained after the required weight loss has been achieved.
The development of our aerobic exercise program is part of the ongoing development of an effective pediatric body weight management program. The overall goals of the program are loss of fat mass, body weight maintenance and behavior modification.
Aerobic exercise program
The training group exercised three times a week for 12 weeks. Twice a week in a gymnasium or outdoors and once a week in a swimming pool. The sessions were taken in groups as adolescents feel less inhibited when they exercise in the company of other obese subjects. The standardized training sessions were led by an exercise therapist (physical education teacher). Specific written instructions in the form of a booklet were given to the exercise therapist. Each session lasted 30–60 minutes (mean duration of exercise sessions 43 minutes). We used a structured modular program that enables us to include new patients at any point during the exercise program. In order to increase the physical skills of the obese participants we incorporated a variety of indoor, outdoor and swimming activities in our exercise program.
• Sport games: basketball, handball, korfball (Dutch sports game), field hockey
○ 1 or 2 sets of 3–4 exercises; exercise period 3 to 5 minutes; work-rest ratio between exercises 1:1/2 or 1:1/3 depending on exercise period and level of aerobic fitness; rest between sets 1 to 3 minutes; passive rest recovery (standing or walking at a low pace).
○ sports game: 10 minutes, two teams, adapted rules to ensure an adequate and substantial aerobic challenge.
• Circuits: 2–3 sets; 4–6 exercises; exercise period 1–12 minutes depending on type of circuit; work-rest ratio between exercises 1:1/2 or 1/4 depending on exercise period and/or level of aerobic fitness; rest between sets 1 to 3 minutes; passive rest recovery (standing or walking at a slow pace).
• Running lanes: 2 sets; 5 exercises; exercise period 3–4 minutes; work-rest ratio between exercises 1:1/2 or 1:1/3 depending on exercise period and/or level of aerobic fitness; rest between sets 2 minutes; passive rest recovery (standing or walking at a low pace).
• Tag games: 1–3 games; 1–10 sets depending on number of children; exercise period 3 to 10 minutes; work-rest ratio 1:1/2 or 1:1/3 depending on exercise period; passive rest recovery in which instructions are given how playing the game can be improved or new games are explained.
• Triathlon: Subsequently exercising on either a normal bicycle or a mountain bike and a kick board followed by swimming. If this was difficult (depending mainly on body mass), the participants use a home trainer (inside) instead of a bicycle/mountain bike and/or walk instead of using the kick board. This differentiation depends mainly on body mass. Exercise period 12 minutes cycle, 12 minutes kick board or walking; no rest between cycling and using a kick board or walking.
Swimming: exercise period 12 minutes; rest between using a kick board or walking and swimming 5 minutes (in which the participants change in to their bathing suits).
• Swim jogging: 1 set; exercise period 30 minutes; every 10 laps (= 150 meters) the participants are informed about their swimming speed; style of swimming is free
○ 1–3 sets of 3–6 exercises; exercise period 1 minute; work-rest ratio between exercises 1:1/2; rest between sets 2 minutes; passive rest recovery (float in the water or slow swimming).
○ sports game: 12–15 minutes, two teams, adapted rules to ensure an adequate and substantial aerobic challenge.
• Aqua jogging/aqua fitness: 1–2 sets of 4–6 exercises; exercise period 1 minute; work-rest ratio between exercises 1:1/2; rest between sets 2 minutes; passive rest recovery (float in the water or slow swimming).
• Swimming lanes and games: 1–2 sets; 3–4 exercises; exercise period 1–8 minutes; work-rest ratio between exercises 1: 1/4–1/2 depending on exercise period or number of participants; rest between sets 2 minutes; passive rest recovery (float in the water or slow swimming)
During the training sessions, heart rate was measured continuously with a heart rate monitor (Polar Electro Sports Tester S610) and the children were instructed how to use the Polar watches during the exercise sessions: the heart rate had to be at least at their individual training heart rate. The heart rate monitor provided instant feedback (beeping sound) whenever the heart rate became below the target training heart rate, so the children knew when to increase their exercise intensity. During the session, they were continuously encouraged to exercise at their set training heart rate and to increase their speed of movement whenever the heart rate monitor gave a signal. The children were instructed not to increase their movement intensity when the target heart rate was reached. We wanted an indication to which extent the target training heart rates were reached by the participants. Therefore we recorded heart rates in the beginning, in the middle and at the end of the exercise program.
Due to the low self esteem normally seen in the pediatric obesity population[6, 46] and to assure successful participation, the training program starts with a training intensity of 50% HRmax. The activities were designed to keep the level of skill low. In order to induce a training effect, later on in the exercise program we changed over to activities with intensities that were more physiological challenging. This balances physiological training with self-confidence and perceived physical efficacy.
In order to provide an overload, every two weeks the clinical exercise physiologist decided if the exercise intensity could be increased by 5 percent during the next exercise class.
Body composition (nutritional assessment)
Obesity was defined according to BMI based international cut off points for body mass index. Body weight was measured using a platform beam balance (Seca, Germany) with an accuracy of 0.02 kg. Height was measured with a stadiometer (Holtain, Crymich, UK) with an accuracy of 0.1 cm. Body mass index (BMI) was determined (body weight·height-2). Standard deviation scores (z-scores, expressed in sd units) were calculated for BMI (sds-BMI), body weight (sds-body weight) and height (sds-height) from a Dutch reference population [4th Dutch growth study 1997, TNO, The Netherlands].
Fat-free mass (FFM) and fat mass (FM) were determined in the morning after an overnight fast by bioelectrical impedance analysis. Bioelectrical impedance analysis has been shown to be a valid and easy to perform method for the assessment of body composition in pediatric obesity[35, 48–50]. Prior to measurements subjects were asked to empty their bladder. Total body resistance was measured by a bioelectrical impedance analyzer (RJL systems, Gouda, The Netherlands, Model BIA 101/S) in supine position. Two electrodes were placed on the dorsal surface of the right hand and foot just proximal to the third metacarpal-phalangeal and metatarsal-phalangeal joints, respectively. Two further electrodes were placed on the dorsal surface of the wrist at the level of the ulnar tubercle, and on the dorsal surface of the right foot between the medial and lateral malleoli.
Aerobic exercise tests were performed on an electronically braked cycle ergometer (Lode Excalibur, Groningen, The Netherlands). All subjects were familiarized with the test and equipment used. Standardized verbal encouragement was given throughout the test to stimulate maximal performance.
Aerobic fitness was assessed by a standard progressive incremental exercise test. Workload was increased by 20 W at 1-minute intervals. The maximal workload (Wmax) was defined as the highest workload maintained during 30 seconds. Continuous respiratory gas analysis and volume measurements, oxygen uptake (VO2), and carbon dioxide production (VCO2), were performed breath by breath with a triple V valve less mouthpiece and stored in a computerized exercise system (Oxycon Champion, Jaeger, Breda, The Netherlands). Prior to each test, internal gas and volume calibrations were made with certified gases of known standard concentrations. Heart rate was monitored continuously during the tests by 3-leads electrocardiogram (Hewlett-Packard, Amstelveen, The Netherlands). Other measurements taken included ventilation (VE) and respiratory exchange ratio (RER= VCO2/VO2). The highest VO2 achieved during the last minute of exercise was taken as VO2 peak.
The efficiency of the cardiovascular system during maximal exercise was evaluated using the oxygen pulse (VO2/HR). The oxygen pulse is a non-invasive index of the efficiency of the ability of the body to transport oxygen to the working tissue, with more fit subjects having a higher oxygen pulse as compared to less fit subjects.
Efforts were considered to be at a maximum level if at least two out of three of the following criteria were met: 1) cardiac frequency above 195 beats/min; 2) maximal respiratory exchange ratio (i.e. VCO2/VO2 above 1.0); 3) subjects showed clinical signs of intense effort and were unable to maintain speed above 50 rpm.
Predicted VO2 peak (VO2 peak%) values were obtained from an age and gender matched Dutch reference population.
Modified shuttle test
The MST is a standardized 15-level externally paced test for use in adult cystic fibrosis. The test requires the subject to walk up and down a 10-meter course identified by two cones with the walking speed dictated by a prerecorded audio signal. The first speed (0.50 m/s) of walking is referred to as level 1, the second as level 2 and so on. Each level lasts for 1 minute and it continues for 15 levels. The audio set emits a single bleep at regular intervals. The subject should aim to be at the opposite end to the start by the time the bleep sounds. After every minute, the speed of walking is increased by a small increment (0.17 m/s), so the subject walks progressively faster; this is indicated by a triple bleep. Subjects are permitted to run at any time during the test. To help the subjects establish the first very slow speed of walking the operator walks alongside for the first minute.
Heart rate was measured at 5-s intervals using a short-range telemetry device (Polar Electro Sports Tester S610). As with the maximal cycle exercise, standardized verbal encouragement was given throughout the test to stimulate maximal performance. The test was ended when 1) the patient was too tired to maintain the required speed or 2) the patient twice failed to complete a shuttle in the time allowed (more than 0,5 m away from the cone when the bleep sounded). The MST walking distance is the distance walked up and down the 10 m course to the last fully completed cone.
Data are presented as mean ± SD. Changes within the aerobic exercise group were analyzed with a two-tailed paired t-test. Pearson correlation analyses and linear regression analyses were performed for the modified shuttle test with aerobic indices. Data were analyzed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS, version 12.0, Chicago. IL, USA).
The construct validity of the MST was measured by relating the instrument to a gold standard: peak oxygen uptake in the progressive incremental exercise test. Correlations between the MST walking distance and aerobic indices were computed.
In order to obtain the test-retest reliability the MST was repeated after two days. The test-retest reliability was studied by computing both the intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) and the Pearson correlation coefficient between the two assessments.
Pearson correlations between MST and the independent variables were also computed. Stepwise regressions of the significant correlations (p < 0.05) were done to evaluate the contribution of the independent variables to MST walking distance results.
In order to study the sensitivity to change, the MST was used as a functional aerobic outcome measure in the aerobic training study. Sensitivity to change was computed using effect sizes (ES): the observed change divided by the standard deviation of that change. We used Cohen's cut points: ES > 0.2 represents a small change, >0.5 a moderate change, >0.8 is a large change. Effect sizes above 0.5 often indicate clinically relevant changes.
The baseline characteristics of the 15 adolescents (mean age: 14.7 ± 2.1 year) who agreed to participate in the aerobic training program are shown in table 1. All subjects were obese (sdsBMI 3.23 ± 0.28).
Since this was a feasibility study, we assured that all adolescents participating in the training program had been exposed to a substantial physical training dose. All 15 participants met the criterion of three times per week and HR equal to or above their individual training HR. In week 1–2, 95% of the heart rates were according to or above the target training heart rate, in week 5–8, 75% and in week 11–12, 82%. The participants enjoyed the program and only one participant missed a training session due to illness.
The baseline and end of training anthropometric characteristics are shown in table 1. Comparing pretraining and end of training period, a significant increase was found for height (0.4%) and significant decreases were found for sds-height (0.3%), body weight (10.6%), sds-body weight (23.9%), BMI (12.6%), sds-BMI (12.5%), total body fat (8.8%) and fat free mass (FFM) (4.8%). All variables showed large changes as indicated by the effect sizes (see table 1).
The changes observed after the 12-week training period for aerobic performance are shown in table 2. Both maximal exercise tests (cycle ergometer and modified shuttle test) were well tolerated by all participants. During the cycle ergometer tests at baseline and at the end of the 12-week training period, mean RER and mean HRmax were respectively, 1.2 ± 0.07, 182.6 ± 7.1 and 1.2 ± 0.06, 185.3 ± 7.1 (table 2). All participants fulfilled at least two criteria for a maximal aerobic exercise test at baseline and at the end of the 12-week training period.
There were significant improvements in VO2 peak (mL/min: 17.5%; mL/kg·min: 31.3%; mL/kg·FFM: 23.1%; and %predicted: 16.5%), Wmax (W: 8%; W/kg·FFM: 14.7%), and VO2 peak/HRmax (15.8%). The MST walking distance improved significantly by 32.5%. No changes were found in HRmax, neither for the cycle ergometer test nor for the modified shuttle.
Modified shuttle walk
Significant correlations were found for the MST with aerobic indices: VO2 peak (r = 0.79, p < 0.001) and Wmax (r = 0.84, p < 0.001). Simple regression analysis indicated that VO2 peak and Wmax accounted for 86% of the variance in the MST walking distance (62% and 71% respectively). None of the anthropometric measures were significantly related to the MST (table 3), despite the moderate correlations of age and height with the MST. The test-retest reliability analysis showed strong intra-class (r = 0.96) and Pearson product moment correlations between the first and second test (r = 0.92). The ICC between peak heart rate from MST and maximal cycle ergometry was r = 0.79. The MST walking distance showed a large relevant clinical change (see table 2).
Discussion and conclusion
We developed and preliminary evaluated a varied and structured aerobic exercise program for adolescents with severe obesity, and assessed the feasibility of the MST for evaluating aerobic fitness.
The exercise program consists of 12 week, 3 times a week aerobic training with diverse indoor, outdoor and swimming activities. Results from the pilot group of 15 adolescents show a marked improvement in aerobic fitness as measured by peak oxygen uptake, peak work rate, peak oxygen pulse and walking distance. There was also a significant decrease in body weight, sds-body weight, BMI and sds-BMI. The participation rate of this inpatient exercise program was high: 99,8%. The modified shuttle test shows to be a valid, reliable and sensitive outcome.
We showed that our aerobic exercise program effectively improved aerobic performance of adolescents with obesity. Exercise treatments are designed to increase energy expenditure or to increase negative energy balance, although the major impact on energy balance occurs through decreasing caloric intake[7, 57]. The effects of exercise can add to dietary interventions to enhance loss of fat mass and improve long-term maintenance i.e. potentiate maintenance of changes in body composition. In addition, aerobic fitness is an important predictor of mortality.
In order to induce a training effect, other studies used a training heart rate for the total group, usually HR > 150 beats/min[8, 30, 32, 58, 59]. Ebbeling et al mention an average HR 60–70% of estimated HR (i.e. 220-age) and no change in training intensity. This does not create an overload during the program, which is important for obtaining a training result. These studies do not take into account the individual differences in maximum HR and rate of improvement of fitness. In the present study exercise intensity was individualized to prevent that some subjects receive insufficient physiological stimulation and others are over stimulated. To optimize results we used individual target training heart rates based on the maximal heart rate obtained during a maximal progressive exercise test. There was a difference between the individual target training HR and the measured HR. We observed that synchronization between starting a new exercise and reaching the higher target training heart rate takes some time. This likely explaines the lower percentage of time of training at the target training heart rate.
Notably, we found a reduction in FFM. The energy deficit caused by the combination of diet and exercise program was very severe: the energy insult produced a 3 kg reduction in FFM despite high loads of exercise. Due to a body weight reduction program FFM is lost, resulting in a decrease in metabolic rate which is a major risk factor for (re)gain of body weight. Physical activity has an anabolic effect on muscle protein metabolism, resulting in an increase in fat-free mass[34, 62]. Figueroa-Colon showed a reduction in body weight and body fat after a 10-week intervention with daily aerobic exercise together with a protein-sparing diet but no change in FFM. To seperate the anabolic effect of our exercise program from the catabolic effect of the dietary intervention a randomized controlled study should be conducted with several intervention groups; exercise only, exercise + diet, and diet only. We were not primarily interested in the effects of exercise on β oxidation but in the feasibility of the exercise program and its effects on aerobic fitness. Although longer duration of activities is consistent with the reliance on β oxidation rather than glycolysis as the primary energy source, we think that longer duration of activities is boring for the pediatric population. Therefore, our program has an interval and circuit-like format with relatively short duration of activities. This way we could also keep the participants (who generally have a short attention span) focused on the exercise program.
This study also shows that the MST is a valid, reliable and sensitive measure of aerobic fitness in adolescents with severe obesity. We found strong and highly significant correlations between the distance walked on the MST and aerobic indices. Our results are in agreement with the study of Van Mechelen et al. They validated the maximal multistage 20-meter shuttle run test by Leger et al as an estimate of aerobic fitness and found a correlation of 0.76 between run performance and aerobic fitness in adolescents who are not overweight. We also found a strong positive correlation (r = 0.79) between the MST and VO2 peak. In their study as well as in our study a large part of the variation in the MST was explained by VO2 peak: 58% and 62% respectively. Although the 20-meter shuttle run test is a valid measure of aerobic fitness in adolescents, the running speed at the beginning of the test is too high and therefore not suitable for adolescents with severe obesity. The modified shuttle test provides an excellent alternative.
One-mile walk/run performance is related to VO2 peak in children who are not overweight[64, 65]. However, Rowland et al concluded that one-mile run performance may not serve as a strong indicator of cardiovascular fitness. Drinkard et al. validated the 12-minute walk/run test as a predictor of peak oxygen uptake in adolescents with obesity. They found a correlation of 0.72 between the 12-minute walk/run distance and VO2 peak. Self-paced tests, such as the 6 and 12 minute, and one-mile walk/run have been criticized because they can be influenced by subject motivation, contain limited information about physiological changes and are poorly standardized. Lack of standardization in areas know to potentially influence results could impose considerable difficulty in interpreting and comparing walk test results obtained before and after an exercise intervention. The MST is an externally paced maximal incremental field test stressing the patient to an individual symptom limited maximal performance which is independent of body weight. A test that is incremental in nature is advantageous when assessing the outcomes of an exercise program due to the ability to compare pre-training and post-training responses at equivalent exercise intensities.
This study has also shown that the MST is suitable for assessing the outcome of interventions aimed at improving aerobic fitness and/or fat mass reduction. Next to the improvement in VO2 peak (mL/min) as a result of the aerobic training program, an even larger improvement was found in the distance walked in the MST. This MST improvement was close to the improvement in relative VO2 peak (mL/kg·min). This might be explained by the suggestion that obese individuals require a greater portion of their aerobic capacity to move their heavier body mass and since they lost a significant amount of body weight, improvements are probably better reflected in VO2 peak per kg body body weight. However, the improvement in absolute VO2 peak was also considerable. The ICC between the distance walked on test 1 and 2 was close to 1. In addition, there was no significant difference between HRmax on test 1 and test 2. These results suggest that a practice walk is not necessary to ensure reliable results in adolescents with severe obesity.
The MST is a suitable test for assessing the physiological capacity in adolescents with obesity, with a greater increase in walking/running speed to stress the more able subjects and because of the slow increase in speed it caters the subjects with less aerobic capacity as well.
These findings have important practical implications regarding the use of the MST as a routine repeatable measure of aerobic fitness in adolescents with obesity. In addition, these results suggest that the MST may be of value in assessing the outcome of exercise interventions with or without body weight reduction.
For reasons of practicability, the MST should be preferred to formal incremental exercise testing. The test can be done in small groups and takes less time to be administered compared to more formal individual exercise tests, which require specialized equipment or expertise. Measuring VO2 peak is in our own experience and that of other authors an unpleasant experience for children and adolescents and especially for children and adolescents with obesity. The normal pretest anxiety in measuring peak oxygen consumption may be magnified in this population. As the peak heart rates at the end of the MST and the maximal cycle ergometer test are very similar, the MST peak heart rate can possibly be used to determine the individual target training heart rates. This way, maximal cycle ergometer testing can be omitted without loss of necessary information.
In conclusion, our results show that participation in a varied and structured aerobic exercise program leads to considerable improvements in aerobic performance of adolescents with severe obesity as measured by maximal cycle ergometry (peak oxygen uptake) and the modified shuttle test. We feel that the large improvements in aerobic fitness are not the resultant of diet or growth. A randomized controlled trial is necessary to confirm the value of our exercise program in which, next to aerobic fitness, data on self-efficacy and quality of life, and long-term outcome need to be obtained. The modified shuttle test is an easily administered, reproducible, standardized exercise test for aerobic capacity of adolescents with obesity and easier to administer than a maximal cycle ergometer test. We recommend its use in body weight management programs.
body mass index
modified shuttle test
respiratory exchange ratio
- VO2 peak :
peak oxygen uptake
- Wmax :
Troiano RP, Flegal KM, Kuczmarski RJ, Campbell SM, Johnson CL: Overweight prevalence and trends for children and adolescents. The National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys, 1963 to 1991. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1995, 149: 1085-1091.
World Health Organisation: Obesity: preventing and managing the global epidemic. Report of a WHO consultation, Geneva, 3-5 jun 1997. 1998, Geneva; WHO., (WHO/NUT/98.1)
Ebbeling CB, Rodriguez NR: Effects of exercise combined with diet therapy on protein utilization in obese children. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999, 31: 378-385. 10.1097/00005768-199903000-00005.
Hirasing RA, Fredriks AM, van Buuren S, Verloove-Vanhorick SP, Wit JM: [Increased prevalence of overweight and obesity in Dutch children, and the detection of overweight and obesity using international criteria and new reference diagrams]. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 2001, 145: 1303-1308.
Epstein LH, Coleman KJ, Myers MD: Exercise in treating obesity in children and adolescents. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1996, 28: 428-435.
Watts K, Jones TW, Davis EA, Green D: Exercise training in obese children and adolescents: current concepts. Sports Med. 2005, 35: 375-392. 10.2165/00007256-200535050-00002.
Epstein LH, Myers MD, Raynor HA, Saelens BE: Treatment of pediatric obesity. Pediatrics. 1998, 101: 554-570.
Owens S, Gutin B, Allison J, Riggs S, Ferguson M, Litaker M, Thompson W: Effect of physical training on total and visceral fat in obese children. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999, 31: 143-148. 10.1097/00005768-199901000-00022.
Berenson GS: Causation of cardiovascular risk factors in children: Perspectives on cardiovascular risk in early life. Edited by: Berenson GS. 1986, New York, Raven Press, 408-428.
Thompson CE, Wankel LM: The effects of perceived activity choice upon frequency of exercise behavior. J Appl Soc Psychol. 1980, 10: 436-443. 10.1111/j.1559-1816.1980.tb00722.x.
Bar-Or O: Physical activity and physical training in childhood obesity. J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 1993, 33: 323-329.
Epstein LH, Goldfield GS: Physical activity in the treatment of childhood overweight and obesity: current evidence and research issues. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999, 31: S553-S559. 10.1097/00005768-199911001-00011.
Sonstroem RJ, Morgan WP: Exercise and self-esteem: rationale and model. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1989, 21: 329-337.
Epstein LH, Paluch RA, Gordy CC, Dorn J: Decreasing sedentary behaviors in treating pediatric obesity. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2000, 154: 220-226.
Calles-Escandon J, Horton ES: The thermogenic role of exercise in the treatment of morbid obesity: a critical evaluation. Am J Clin Nutr. 1992, 55: 533S-537S.
Rowlands AV, Ingledew DK, Eston RG: The effect of type of physical activity measure on the relationship between body fatness and habitual physical activity in children: a meta-analysis. Ann Hum Biol. 2000, 27: 479-497. 10.1080/030144600419314.
Lee CD, Blair SN, Jackson AS: Cardiorespiratory fitness, body composition, and all-cause and cardiovascular disease mortality in men. Am J Clin Nutr. 1999, 69: 373-380.
McMurray RG, Ainsworth BE, Harrell JS, Griggs TR, Williams OD: Is physical activity or aerobic power more influential on reducing cardiovascular disease risk factors?. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1998, 30: 1521-1529. 10.1097/00005768-199810000-00009.
Blair SN, Kohl HW, Barlow CE, Paffenbarger RS, Gibbons LW, Macera CA: Changes in physical fitness and all-cause mortality. A prospective study of healthy and unhealthy men. JAMA. 1995, 273: 1093-1098. 10.1001/jama.273.14.1093.
Blair SN, Kohl HW, Paffenbarger RS, Clark DG, Cooper KH, Gibbons LW: Physical fitness and all-cause mortality. A prospective study of healthy men and women. JAMA. 1989, 262: 2395-2401. 10.1001/jama.262.17.2395.
Farrell SW, Kampert JB, Kohl HW, Barlow CE, Macera CA, Paffenbarger RS, Gibbons LW, Blair SN: Influences of cardiorespiratory fitness levels and other predictors on cardiovascular disease mortality in men. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1998, 30: 899-905. 10.1097/00005768-199806000-00019.
Blair SN, Kampert JB, Kohl HW, Barlow CE, Macera CA, Paffenbarger RS, Gibbons LW: Influences of cardiorespiratory fitness and other precursors on cardiovascular disease and all-cause mortality in men and women. JAMA. 1996, 276: 205-210. 10.1001/jama.276.3.205.
Lee CD, Jackson AS, Blair SN: US weight guidelines: is it also important to consider cardiorespiratory fitness?. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 1998, 22 Suppl 2: S2-S7.
Farrell SW, Braun L, Barlow CE, Cheng YJ, Blair SN: The relation of body mass index, cardiorespiratory fitness, and all-cause mortality in women. Obes Res. 2002, 10: 417-423.
Blair SN, Brodney S: Effects of physical inactivity and obesity on morbidity and mortality: current evidence and research issues. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999, 31: S646-S662. 10.1097/00005768-199911001-00025.
Watts K, Beye P, Siafarikas A, Davis EA, Jones TW, O'Driscoll G, Green DJ: Exercise training normalizes vascular dysfunction and improves central adiposity in obese adolescents. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2004, 43: 1823-1827. 10.1016/j.jacc.2004.01.032.
Watts K, Beye P, Siafarikas A, O'Driscoll G, Jones TW, Davis EA, Green DJ: Effects of exercise training on vascular function in obese children. J Pediatr. 2004, 144: 620-625. 10.1016/j.jpeds.2004.02.027.
Woo KS, Chook P, Yu CW, Sung RY, Qiao M, Leung SS, Lam CW, Metreweli C, Celermajer DS: Effects of diet and exercise on obesity-related vascular dysfunction in children. Circulation. 2004, 109: 1981-1986. 10.1161/01.CIR.0000126599.47470.BE.
Riddoch C: Relationships between physical activity and physical health in young people. Young and active? Young people and health-enhancing physical activity; evidence and implications. Edited by: Biddle S, Sallis J and Cavill N. 1998, London, Health Education Authority
Barbeau P, Gutin B, Litaker M, Owens S, Riggs S, Okuyama T: Correlates of individual differences in body-composition changes resulting from physical training in obese children. Am J Clin Nutr. 1999, 69: 705-711.
Epstein LH, Valoski AM, Vara LS, McCurley J, Wisniewski L, Kalarchian MA, Klein KR, Shrager LR: Effects of decreasing sedentary behavior and increasing activity on weight change in obese children. Health Psychol. 1995, 14: 109-115. 10.1037/0278-6220.127.116.11.
Ferguson MA, Gutin B, Le NA, Karp W, Litaker M, Humphries M, Okuyama T, Riggs S, Owens S: Effects of exercise training and its cessation on components of the insulin resistance syndrome in obese children. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 1999, 23: 889-895. 10.1038/sj.ijo.0800968.
Reybrouck T, Vinckx J, Van den BG, Vanderschueren-Lodeweyckx M: Exercise therapy and hypocaloric diet in the treatment of obese children and adolescents. Acta Paediatr Scand. 1990, 79: 84-89.
Sasaki J, Shindo M, Tanaka H, Ando M, Arakawa K: A long-term aerobic exercise program decreases the obesity index and increases the high density lipoprotein cholesterol concentration in obese children. Int J Obes. 1987, 11: 339-345.
Schwingshandl J, Borkenstein M: Changes in lean body mass in obese children during a weight reduction program: effect on short term and long term outcome. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 1995, 19: 752-755.
Bar-Or O: Juvenile obesity, physical activity, and lifestyle changes. The Physician and Sports Medicine. 2000, 28:
Reynolds KD, Killen JD, Bryson SW, Maron DJ, Taylor CB, Maccoby N, Farquhar JW: Psychosocial predictors of physical activity in adolescents. Prev Med. 1990, 19: 541-551. 10.1016/0091-7435(90)90052-L.
Turner SE, Eastwood PR, Cecins NM, Hillman DR, Jenkins SC: Physiologic responses to incremental and self-paced exercise in COPD: a comparison of three tests. Chest. 2004, 126: 766-773. 10.1378/chest.126.3.766.
Bradley J, Howard J, Wallace E, Elborn S: Reliability, repeatability, and sensitivity of the modified shuttle test in adult cystic fibrosis. Chest. 2000, 117: 1666-1671. 10.1378/chest.117.6.1666.
Drinkard B, McDuffie J, McCann S, Uwaifo GI, Nicholson J, Yanovski JA: Relationships between walk/run performance and cardiorespiratory fitness in adolescents who are overweight. Phys Ther. 2001, 81: 1889-1896.
Leger LA, Lambert J: A maximal multistage 20-m shuttle run test to predict VO2 max. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol. 1982, 49: 1-12. 10.1007/BF00428958.
Leger LA, Mercier D, Gadoury C, Lambert J: The multistage 20 metre shuttle run test for aerobic fitness. J Sports Sci. 1988, 6: 93-101.
van Mechelen W, Hlobil H, Kemper HC: Validation of two running tests as estimates of maximal aerobic power in children. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol. 1986, 55: 503-506. 10.1007/BF00421645.
Schofield WN: Predicting basal metabolic rate, new standards and review of previous work. Hum Nutr Clin Nutr. 1985, 39 Suppl 1: 5-41.
Armstrong N, Welsman J: Physical activity and aerobic fitness. Young peolple and physical activity. Edited by: Armstrong N and Welsman J. 1997, New York, Oxford University Press, 122-136.
Owens S, Gutin B: Exercise testing of the child with obesity. Pediatr Cardiol. 1999, 20: 79-83. 10.1007/s002469900405.
Cole TJ, Bellizzi MC, Flegal KM, Dietz WH: Establishing a standard definition for child overweight and obesity worldwide: international survey. BMJ. 2000, 320: 1240-1243. 10.1136/bmj.320.7244.1240.
Schaefer F, Georgi M, Zieger A, Scharer K: Usefulness of bioelectric impedance and skinfold measurements in predicting fat-free mass derived from total body potassium in children. Pediatr Res. 1994, 35: 617-624. 10.1203/00006450-199405000-00016.
Deurenberg P, Kusters CS, Smit HE: Assessment of body composition by bioelectrical impedance in children and young adults is strongly age-dependent. Eur J Clin Nutr. 1990, 44: 261-268.
Goran MI, Kaskoun MC, Carpenter WH, Poehlman ET, Ravussin E, Fontvieille AM: Estimating body composition of young children by using bioelectrical resistance. J Appl Physiol. 1993, 75: 1776-1780.
Binkhorst RA, van 't Hof MA, Saris WHM: Maximum exercise in children; Reference-values for 6-18 years ols girls and boys. Edited by: Binkhorst RA, van 't Hof MA and Saris WHM. 1992, The Hague, The Netherlands, Dutch Heart Association
Streiner DL, Norman GR: Health measurements scales. Edited by: Streiner DL and Norman GR. 2003, Oxford, University Press, Third edition
Rowland TW: Development exercise physiology. 1996, Champaign, IL, Human Kinetics
Bradley J, Howard J, Wallace E, Elborn S: Validity of a modified shuttle test in adult cystic fibrosis. Thorax. 1999, 54: 437-439.
Cohen J: Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 1988, Hillsdale, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
Norman GR, Sloan JA, Wyrwich KW: Interpretation of changes in health-related quality of life: the remarkable universality of half a standard deviation. Medical Care. 2003, 41: 582-592. 10.1097/00005650-200305000-00004.
Wing RR, Jeffery RW: Outpatient treatments of obesity: a comparison of methodology and clinical results. Int J Obes. 1979, 3: 261-279.
Gutin B, Riggs S, Ferguson M, Owens S: Description and process evaluation of a physical training program for obese children. Res Q Exerc Sport. 1999, 70: 65-69.
Ferguson MA, Gutin B, Owens S, Barbeau P, Tracy RP, Litaker M: Effects of physical training and its cessation on the hemostatic system of obese children. Am J Clin Nutr. 1999, 69: 1130-1134.
American College of Sports Medicine: American College of Sports Medicine Position Stand. The recommended quantity and quality of exercise for developing and maintaining cardiorespiratory and muscular fitness, and flexibility in healthy adults. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1998, 30: 975-991. 10.1097/00005768-199806000-00032.
Zwiauer KF: Prevention and treatment of overweight and obesity in children and adolescents. Eur J Pediatr. 2000, 159 Suppl 1: S56-S68. 10.1007/PL00014367.
Blaak EE, Bar-Or O, Westerterp KR, al : Effects of VLCD on daily energy expenditure and body composition in obese boy, abstracted. Int J Obes. 1990, 14 (suppl 2): 86-
Figueroa-Colon R, von Almen TK, Franklin FA, Schuftan C, Suskind RM: Comparison of two hypocaloric diets in obese children. Am J Dis Child. 1993, 147: 160-166.
McCormack WP, Cureton KJ, Bullock TA, Weyand PG: Metabolic determinants of 1-mile run/walk performance in children. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1991, 23: 611-617.
Cureton KJ, Sloniger MA, O'Bannon JP, Black DM, McCormack WP: A generalized equation for prediction of VO2peak from 1-mile run/walk performance. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1995, 27: 445-451.
Rowland T, Kline G, Goff D, Martel L, Ferrone L: One-mile run performance and cardiovascular fitness in children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1999, 153: 845-849.
Guyatt GH, Pugsley SO, Sullivan MJ, Thompson PJ, Berman L, Jones NL, Fallen EL, Taylor DW: Effect of encouragement on walking test performance. Thorax. 1984, 39: 818-822.
Singh SJ, Morgan MD, Scott S, Walters D, Hardman AE: Development of a shuttle walking test of disability in patients with chronic airways obstruction. Thorax. 1992, 47: 1019-1024.
Elpern EH, Stevens D, Kesten S: Variability in performance of timed walk tests in pulmonary rehabilitation programs. Chest. 2000, 118: 98-105. 10.1378/chest.118.1.98. [http://www.PM:10893366]
Goran M, Fields DA, Hunter GR, Herd SL, Weinsier RL: Total body fat does not influence maximal aerobic capacity. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 2000, 24: 841-848. 10.1038/sj.ijo.0801241.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2431/7/19/prepub
This study was partially supported by a research grant from STEA friends of Heideheuvel.
The authors would like to thank Alice Scholte and Sietske Tamminga for assistance with exercise testing. The authors are indebted to Monique Klijn-Legemaat for careful data management and preparing the manuscript.
Declaration of competing interests
The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.
PHCK conceived of the study, and participated in its design and coordination, performed the statistical analysis and drafted the manuscript. OvdB-S participated in the coordination and helped to draft the manuscript. HFvS participated in its design and the statistical analysis and helped to draft the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
About this article
Cite this article
Klijn, P.H., van der Baan-Slootweg, O.H. & van Stel, H.F. Aerobic exercise in adolescents with obesity: preliminary evaluation of a modular training program and the modified shuttle test. BMC Pediatr 7, 19 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2431-7-19
- Exercise Program
- Aerobic Training
- Aerobic Fitness
- Exercise Period
- Aerobic Exercise Program