This study demonstrated a strong correlation between TcB and TSB measured at both the forehead and midsternum of ethnic Mongolian neonates. Since Yasuda et al. [10] published the accuracy of TcB measurement in Japanese neonates, several validations in diagnostic studies have been performed [11–16]. Regarding other Asian populations, a strong correlation between TcB and TSB was reported in a study in Thailand [14]. However, a study in Chinese newborns suggested that there was a significant difference between TcB and TSB [15]. In a previous study in an African American population, there was a lower correlation between the two measurements [11], but other populations, such as Caucasians and Europeans, showed a strong correlation [12, 13, 16]. The accuracy of TcB in our study was similar to that in some validated populations. A multi-ethnic population in the United States showed TcB AUC of 0.962 at 10 mg/dL TSB, 0.963 at 13 mg/dL, and 0.975 at 15 mg/dL [11], an Israeli population showed AUC of 0.958 at TSB 10 mg/dL, 0.971 at 13 mg/dL and 0.976 at 15 mg/dL, [13], and a Thai population showed AUC of 0.851 at TSB 10 mg/dL, 0.830 at 13 mg/dL, 0.958 at 15 mg/dL [14]. The study in the Israeli population reported a sensitivity and specificity of 89.4% and 100%, respectively, at TSB 10 mg/dL, of 93.6% and 90.5%, respectively, at 13 mg/dL, and 100% each at 15 mg/dL [13]. In the Thai population, sensitivity and specificity were 89.4% and 37.5%, respectively, at TSB 10 mg/dl, 93.6% and 65.7%, respectively, at 13 mg/dL, and 100% and 85.4%, respectively, at 15 mg/dL [14]. Our results validate the use of TcB as an alternative, quick and convenient measure of TSB in ethnic Mongolian neonates.
There are a number of previous reports of the comparison between TcB and TSB, with variability in study design. All hospital-based studies used convenience samples, but there were large variations in the number of infants (minimum 77 [10] and maximum 997 [15]). There were differences in inclusion criteria (e.g., healthy term or late preterm infants), in exclusion criteria (e.g., gestational age less than 35 weeks, receiving phototherapy, ABO incompatibility, Rh incompatibility, major congenital malformation, hemoglobinopathies or evidence of liver disease), in the TcB measurement site (e.g., forehead, midsternum, or both sites), in the number of measurements (1 to 5 times), and in ethnicity. Studies have been performed in Asian populations in Japan [10], Thailand [14], and China [15], and in mixed race countries such as the United States (white, African-American, East Asian, and Middle eastern) [11], Canada (Caucasian and Non-Caucasian) [12], Israel (Ashkenazi, Sephardic, and Ethiopian) [13], and Italy (Caucasian and West African) [16]. In addition, TSB was measured by different methods (e.g., photometric, colorimetric, direct spectrophotometry, and high performance liquid chromatography). Because of these variations, there were no comprehensive studies. Therefore, it was worthwhile to perform this validation study in a resource-limited setting like Mongolia. However, the limitations of our study were that i) the sample size was relatively small compared with previous studies; ii) the analyzed infants had medical indications for admission to a single hospital; and iii) the infants were relatively older than in previous reports. In addition, the Bradley-Blackwood test for all measured ranges of bilirubin did not clearly present equivalence, because our sample size was relatively small and had low statistical power.
As we had limited medical resources, we selected term and late preterm neonates who required re-admittance for visible jaundice and other medical reasons after discharge. We were allowed to take their blood samples, including TSB, for diagnosis and management. The 3-h time difference between sampling for TSB measurement and TcB measurement was relatively long compared with previous studies. However, this longer time period may not affect the differences between TSB and TcB. In most cases (n=45, 84.9%), we performed the measurements at postnatal 6 day or later (Table 1). TSB tends to increase on an hourly basis until day 4 or 5 after birth, then plateaus and decreases gradually [1].
Because the AAP recommends that TcB measurements are accurate and constitute a viable alternative to TSB that can reduce the need for blood sampling, a TcB hour-specific nomogram has been constructed in many countries [20–26]. DeLuca et al. [27] observed that TcB levels plateau and then decrease after 96 h of life in healthy neonates, with some differences across populations. Thus, it is necessary to create a Mongolian ethnicity-specific TcB nomogram in the near future.
The JM-103 meter had good validity. This tool is non-invasive and easy to use, gives prompt measurements, and is minimally influenced by skin pigmentation. Thus, it might afford the possibility of screening jaundice in a home visit setting. The TcB jaundice meter would be suitable for the early detection of subsequent hyperbilirubinemia. Therefore, we would need to create a TcB hour-specific nomogram to prevent severe hyperbilirubinemia in Mongolia.
