Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of studies

From: A systematic review with meta-analysis of the relation of aflatoxin B1 to growth impairment in infants/children

Reference

Year

Study design

Location

N of participants

Age (rang or mean ± sd)

Exposure

Exposure assessment

Mean serum AFB1(mean ± sd, or as mentioned)

Outcomes

Statistical models

Adjustment

Alamua et al.

2019

Cross-sectional

Zambia

311

6–24 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

0.21 ± 0.75 ng/mL

Stunting, underweight

Logistic regression

Sex, sickness, age, serum albumin

Andrews-Trevino et al.

2021

Prospective cohort

Nepal

1484

3 to 22 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

1.27 pg/mg albumin (95%CI: 1.18–1.36)

Stunting, height, WHZ, WAZ, HAZ

Logistic regression

Linear regression

Age, season of measurement, and detectable AFB1 concentrations (yes/no)

Ashraf et al.

2022

Cross-sectional

Pakistan

238

1–11 years

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

11.27 pg/mg albumin (95%CI: 15.88–24.17)

Stunting, underweight, wasting

Logistic regression

Adjusted for potential covariates(not reported)

Mahfuz et al.

2020

Prospective cohort

Bangladesh

228

7–36 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

3.70 pg/mg albumin (range: 0.09 -126.54)

HAZ, Stunting

Logistic regression

Linear regression

Sex, concentrations of myeloperoxidase in stool, low birth weight, maternal height, number of people sleep in one room, improved toilet, treatment of drinking water, asset categories

Andrews‐Trevino et al.

2021

Prospective cohort

Nepal

699

18–22 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

2.41 ± 7.88 pg/mg albumin

Stunting, underweight, height, WAZ, HAZ

Logistic regression

Linear regression

Length, weight or anthropometric z‐scores at birth or head circumference at 3 months, child's minimum dietary diversity (yes/no) and mother's schooling

Shirima et al.

2015

Prospective cohort

Tanzania

166

6–14 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

ELISA

4.7 pg/mg albumin (95%CI: 3.9—5.6)

Height, HAZ

Multivariable regression

Village, breastfeeding, maternal education, and family socioeconomic status and protein and energy intakes, sex, baseline age in month, and baseline length

Tessema et al.

2021

Prospective cohort

Ethiopia

102

6–35 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

NR

WHZ, HAZ

Linear regression

child’s sex, age, time of assessment (pre- or post-harvest), intervention arm, inflammation, household wealth tertile and incidence of diarrhea

Watson et al.

2018

Prospective cohort

Gambia

374

6–18 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

ELISA

52.29 ± 5.61 pg/mg albumin

WHZ, WAZ, HAZ

Linear regression

Season of sampling, mother’s household quality, supplementation group, and age of introduction of non-breast milk foods

Turner et al.

2007

Prospective cohort

Gambia

138

Under 1 year

AFB1-lysine (serum)

ELISA

8.7 pg/mg albumin ( range: 5.0—30.2)

WAZ, HAZ

The generalized estimating equations

multiple regression

Gender, age, placental weight, maternal weight, gestation duration and season

Gong et al.

2003

Cross-sectional

Benin and Togo

479

9 months to 5 years

AFB1-lysine (serum)

ELISA

32.8 pg/mg albumin (95% CI: 25.3—42.5)

WAZ, HAZ

Multivariable regression

Age, sex, socioeconomic status, agro ecological zone, and weaning status

McMillana et al.

2018

Case–control

Nigeria

58

6 – 48 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

2.6 pg/mg albumin (range: 0.2—59.2)

Stunting, WHZ, HAZ

Logistic regression

Spearman's

correlations

Age

Wangia-Dixon et al.

2020

Cross-sectional

Kenya

748

6–12 years

AFB1-lysine (serum)

HPLC

10.5 pg/mg albumin (95%CI: 9.4 -11.7)

WHZ, WAZ, HAZ

Linear regression

County, age of child, go to bed and feel hungry, age of mother when she had first child, marital status, living condition, and mother’s education

Shouman et al.

2011

Cross-sectional

Egypt

46

1 month to 4.5 years

AFB1 (serum)

TLC

51.61 ppm ( interquartile range: 30.565 -62.795)

WAZ, HAZ

Spearman’s correlation

Not adjusted

Castelino et al.

2015

Cross-sectional

Kenya

199

12.0 ± 3.0 years

AFB1-lysine (serum)

ELISA

110.5 pg/mg albumin (95%CI: 95.4 -127.9)

Height

Multivariable regression

Age, sex, school, liver disease state and infection status

Matchado et al.

2023

Prospective cohort

Malawi

241

Under 30 months

AFB1-lysine (serum)

IDMS

NR

WHZ, WAZ, HAZ

Linear regression

Maternal prepregnancy body mass index, HIV, weight and mid-upper-arm-circumference-for-age z-score gain rate from baseline to 36 weeks, housing quality, food security, child sex, age, malaria, hemoglobin

  1. AFB1 Aflatoxin B1, WHZ Weight-for-height z score, WAZ Weight-for-age z-score, HAZ Height-for-age z-scores, HPLC High-performance liquid chromatography, ELISA Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, TLC Thin layer chromatography, IDMS Isotope dilution mass spectrometry, HIV Human immunodeficiency virus, NR Not reported