Skip to main content

Table 1 Formula milk versus donor milk for feeding preterm or low birth weight infants (Cochrane review)

From: DoMINO: Donor milk for improved neurodevelopmental outcomes

Author

Year

Subjects

Comparison

Blind

Primary outcome

Notes

Davies[25]

1977

68 preterm (28–36 weeks)

Term formula vs Donor Milk

No

Slower growth first month for Donor Milk

Uncertain group for 2 infants with mother’s own milk

Gross[26]

1983

67 preterm (27–33 weeks)

Term formula vs Donor Milk

No

Slower growth for term Donor Milk (not preterm Donor Milk)

Infants with feed intolerance/NEC withdrawn from growth analysis

Lucas[27]

1984

159 LBW (<1850 g)

Preterm formula vs Donor Milk

No

Slower growth for Donor Milk; no neurodevelopmental difference

 

Lucas[28]

1984

343 LBW (<1850 g)

Preterm formula vs Donor Milk

No

No neurodevelopmental difference

 

Raiha[29]

1976

106 LBW (<2100 g)

Term formula vs Donor Milk

No

No difference in growth

 

Schanler[30]

2005

173 preterm (<30 weeks)

Term formula vs Fortified Donor Milk

Yes

Slower growth for Donor Milk, no difference in infection events

Only fortified Donor Milk study; 20% cross-over from Donor Milk to Formula

Schultz[31]

1980

20 preterm

Term formula vs Donor Milk

No

No difference in weight gain

 

Tyson[32]

1983

81 LBW (<1500 g)

Preterm formula vs Donor Milk

No

Slower growth for Donor Milk

Donor Milk not pasteurized; Randomized day 10; 5 affected infants withdrawn

  1. Quigley MA, Henderson G, Anthony MY, McGuire W. Formula milk versus donor breast milk for feeding preterm or low birth weight infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2007:CD002971.