Skip to main content

Table 2 Summary of what worked, how it worked, for whom and in what context

From: Effective process or dangerous precipice: qualitative comparative embedded case study with young people with epilepsy and their parents during transition from children’s to adult services

What works

How it works (behavioural response)

For whom

In what context

Multidisciplinary team and joint care in a single combined clinic between children and adult epilepsy services involving paediatrician, neurologist and epilepsy nurse, including:

Young people do not experience the significant change in care pathway, professionals, philosophies and frequency of clinic visits

Young people aged between 14-17 years

In Case 2

Reviewing Epilepsy and drug management early in transition

Young people and parents felt that they were having consistent coordinated expert care, and continuity of epilepsy care

Parents

Joint care between children and adult epilepsy services facilitated in children’s out-patient department of a hospital

Enabling young people to know and engage with adult healthcare professionals via children’s healthcare professionals

Young people were more actively involved in discussion about epilepsy with healthcare professionals

 

NHS care free at the point of delivery

Person-centred communication techniques

Young people and parents responded positively to healthcare professionals using age-appropriate facilitative skills

Specifically commissioned teenage transitional clinic from age 14-17 years (Case 2)

Continuity of care at staged intervals

Young people gained a more realistic prognosis and became more accepting of epilepsy as a long-term condition

Out-patient clinic meeting every 6 months

Continued contact with children’s services during transition

Young people felt the joint clinic in children’s services was a safe environment

 
 

Young people did not feel worried that healthcare professionals in adult services were going to change their anti-epileptic drugs

Healthcare professionals in children’s services befriending young people and making it easier for them to not be intimidated by adult healthcare professionals

Attending the clinic at frequent intervals with their parents if the young person wanted.

Increase self-confidence to self-care and manage epilepsy

Being given age-appropriate information

Greater understanding about epilepsy as information is repeated at frequent intervals and helps overcome some but not all memory impairment

Young people aged 14-17 years

Children epilepsy clinic in Case 1 and Case 2

Healthcare professionals being responsive to the developmental age of the young person

Making links with experience of seizures (what triggers seizures)

Joint care between children and adult services Case 2

Improves self-care by learning practical skills

Continued checking understanding of epilepsy, lifestyle adjustment and medication management at repeated intervals

Improves self-management by improved concordance with medication

Young people aged 16-19 years

Adult epilepsy clinic Case 2

  

Parents

 

Healthcare professionals being receptive to young people’s varying levels of information needs throughout their teenage years

Taking responsibility increases chance of being given more independence

Young people aged 16-19 years

Routine children and adult NHS out-patient epilepsy services

Parents

Irrespective of Case or clinic model or frequency of visits

Addressing biological, psychological, educational needs in healthcare contexts

Young people responded positively to strategies to improve retention of information – such as repeated information even if it annoyed them.

Young people aged 16-19 years

Adult epilepsy clinic Case 2 and

Early identification of memory problems and referral to neuropsychology

They experienced improved psychological coping strategies (especially at school/college)

Parents

Children’s epilepsy clinic Case 1

Early identification of psychological problems and early access to psychological services

They felt an Increase in self-confidence

Support and advice for parents to encourage their child to safe self-care

Healthcare professionals were receptive to the individual information needs of parents and proactively responded should their child’s epilepsy change

Young people aged 14-17 years

Children’s epilepsy clinic Case 1 and Case 2

Providing accurate advice and information about epilepsy in lay language

Parents liked the emotional support as well as practical advice from healthcare professionals

Parents

Joint care between children and adult services Case 2

Providing a realistic prognosis of epilepsy as a long-term condition*

Parents responded positively to opportunities to access to parental support groups to learn from other parents

 

Adult epilepsy clinic Case 1 and Case 2*

Parents self-confidence increased to enable their child to take responsibility

  1. * means only seen in case 2 referring to * in column 4.